Blog Post

Be Cautious About Invoke-SqlCmd Bug

,

With PowerShell becoming more popular in daily DBA work, I’d like to mention one huge ugly bug I recently encountered to, IMHO, an corner-stone cmdlet in SQLPS module, invoke-sqlcmd.

I mentioned this here http://stackoverflow.com/questions/33271446/invoke-sqlcmd-runs-script-twice (and also in MS forum)

But I’ll give a more simplified version here to verify this bug (for SQLPS module of SQL 2012/SQL 2014)

First, let’s create two test tables in TestDB

use testdb
--drop table dbo.s, dbo.t
create table dbo.s (id int identity primary key, b varchar(50));
create table dbo.t (id int primary key, b varchar(50));

Ok, in PowerShell, now let’s just run two t-sql statements, one insert into each table, with the 2nd statement firing an error (I purposely make it error out by not populating the primary key column)

import-module sqlps;
invoke-sqlcmd -Server localhost -Database TestDB -Query "insert into dbo.s (b) values ('Hello'); insert into dbo.t (b) values ('World')"

Now you will see the following error

error

Now, if we check what is in table dbo.s, by select * from dbo.s, we will see two records instead of the expected one record as shown below

result

To me, this bug alone will stop me from using this invoke-sqlcmd, yet without which, SQLPS seems crippled in many cases.

When I try to report this as a bug in MS Connect, I find someone has reported a similar issue before in 2013, yet, MS closed it as “Won’t Fix”, I guess this is another bad decision from some PM who really did not appreciate the importance of this bug.  The MS connect item is here

https://connect.microsoft.com/SQLServer/Feedback/Details/811560

I hope those DBAs who are keen on using SQLPS, please vote it up to let MS change their weird previous decision.

Once SQL 2016 is RTM’ed, I will test it again and see how it goes and report back here.

Rate

You rated this post out of 5. Change rating

Share

Share

Rate

You rated this post out of 5. Change rating