Good and thorough walk-through of the product. I checked Lumigents site and they claim Log Explorer does support SQL Server 2K5 so there is competition.
To be honest, once I start seeing a lot of screen shots I start scrolling past everything. I'm not looking for a step-by-step how-to but rather a summary of how it works and more importantly what you think of it. As such, I think a summary on the pro's and con's of the product would have been good.
I suppose I might think differently if I was actually in the market for a tool like this versus just reading the article for information. I did manage to see the issues you listed with the recovery scripts. Good item to make a note of if I'm ever looking into the tool.
Thank you for your time and effort on putting this together.