## The Dynamic Tally or Numbers Table

 Author Message Lynn Pettis SSC Guru Group: General Forum Members Points: 311459 Visits: 41515 Gianluca Sartori SSC Guru Group: General Forum Members Points: 77985 Visits: 13367 Excellent article, Lynn!I'll make sure to include your oustanding UDF in my dev/production environment. I already have one that does the same thing, in a while loop . Thanks for this content, it will be very useful! --Gianluca SartoriHow to post T-SQL questionsspaghettidba.com@spaghettidba Matt Whitfield SSCertifiable Group: General Forum Members Points: 6495 Visits: 719 Top job Lynn.It's this sort of article that really keeps me on my toes with respect to the SQL I write - there's almost always a better way, and this article has shown me a better way.Really good explanation too. Thanks! :-D Atlantis Interactive - SQL Server ToolsMy blogWhy I wrote a sql query analyzer clone peter-757102 SSCarpal Tunnel Group: General Forum Members Points: 4831 Visits: 2559 I quickly read the article and ran no tests myself, but if all this code is only used to quickly fill a table with numbers then I am perplexed about the complexity as well as the amount of code. We all have seen so many 5 line SQL code solutions that do the same, be it only for tally table generation.If the code is to dynamically generate a list of numbers in a desired range for immediate use in another statement I still find the code rather complex and would like to see comparisons with dozens of other tally solutions that can be found on this site. We all know by now that recursion is not the tool to use for this and to compare it with that doesn’t say much to me.Don't take this the wrong way, but can you clarify to me what the exact intended use is and if you did compare it with similar solutions that are not rooted in recursion? I can see the range and order aspect as something novel compared to pure tally functions, but a function that simply reads a tally table could do the same in a single statment by using some basic math.What required the many staged approach you took? Rob Fisk Ten Centuries Group: General Forum Members Points: 1327 Visits: 428 I agree. Definitely an interesting article but I would have liked to see tests against an already created and indexed tally table and the reasons for going dynamic rather than static since it is quite easy to sort and scale results to any interval/order from a static table.I'll have a look myself of course but for now cannot thing of a reason to use a function over a static tally table. Maybe I'm missing something though. _______________________________________________________Change is inevitable... Except from a vending machine. peter-757102 SSCarpal Tunnel Group: General Forum Members Points: 4831 Visits: 2559 Here is an exampe of generating a range of numbers form an existing tally table or function with numbers starting at 1.`-- Get a range of numbers based on a tally table, the range can be 20bits wide-- (1048576 positions) in this example.declare @min bigint, @max bigint;select @min = 1000000000, @max = 1000000200;select top (@max - @min + 1) (@min - 1) + N from dbo.tally20b;`Even with a 12 bit tally table you can generate ranges of 4096 numbers at any position in the bigint range. Creating intervals is no more then adding a multiplyer (see below):`-- Get a range of numbers based on a tally table, the range can be 20bits wide-- (1048576 positions) in this example. An interval of 10 is used.declare @min bigint, @max bigint;select @min = 1000000000, @max = 1000000200;select top (@max - @min + 1) @min + (10 * (N - 1)) from dbo.tally20b;` Luke L One Orange Chip Group: General Forum Members Points: 26199 Visits: 6153 Rob Fisk (9/22/2009)I agree. Definitely an interesting article but I would have liked to see tests against an already created and indexed tally table and the reasons for going dynamic rather than static since it is quite easy to sort and scale results to any interval/order from a static table.I'll have a look myself of course but for now cannot thing of a reason to use a function over a static tally table. Maybe I'm missing something though.I can't tell you the number of times a tally or numbers table approach has been suggested to someone on the forums here and the response was something to the affect of "I'm not allowed to change the schema" or "I can't get a static table like that approved." Seems like a quick way to dynamically generate a tally table of just the numbers you need would be very helpful in those circumstances...Good thorough description of the code Lynn, and a good read.Thanks,-Luke. To help us help you read thisFor better help with performance problems please read this Rob Fisk Ten Centuries Group: General Forum Members Points: 1327 Visits: 428 Indeed, a very well written, descriptive and, as I said, interesting article. It's already been bookmarked so I can look at the interaction of the various elements in the code later since it seems they could help me with other things I have been looking at.I had completely forgotten the scenario of being able to create functions but not tables. Especially if those tables have no impact on the rest of the schema. I must have been on some happy juice and forgotten what a crazy world wee live in. _______________________________________________________Change is inevitable... Except from a vending machine. dbishop SSC-Addicted Group: General Forum Members Points: 416 Visits: 252 I am a bit perplexed by the article. I buiul a tally table in each of my databases a couple of years ago. Static table, 100K rows, PK. When I initially built it I really did not care if it took 150ms or 1.3 seconds, because it was a one-time thing. A tally table is so useful, it should be part of the SQL installation and be included when a new database is created.An article on how to use a tally table would have been a lot better than how to create one. Likle it was said, there are a lot of articles that provide a 5-line code solution on how to create it all over the place. No reason to be creating one on the fly every time you need it. John Rowan SSC-Forever Group: General Forum Members Points: 41774 Visits: 4676 Great job Lynn! John Rowan ============================================================================================================ Forum Etiquette: How to post data/code on a forum to get the best help - by Jeff Moden