ChrisM@Work (9/9/2013)
Prior to the introduction of MERGE I'd have agreed with this - we learned to ensure that multiple source rows for a target row had the same source value. Now though? It's inconsistent - and changing the behaviour of UPDATE to match the strictness of MERGE would break too much legacy code.
Are you aware of the problems that they've had with MERGE? Some are "problems" with the way people implement it, just like the "problems" with UPDATE.
--Jeff Moden
Change is inevitable... Change for the better is not.