It makes sense to consolidate, especially in the light of service hardening, such as clustering or mirroring technology. It's expensive, but can be better justified by hardening several instances prone to outage.
A+, ITIL, MCAD, MCDBA, MCITP: Sql Server 2005 Adminstration, MCT,
MCTS: Sql Server 2005, MCP, MCSA, MCSE, MOUS, PMP
President and Founder S3oLV.Com: Sql Server Society of Las Vegas
President and Founder LVXUG.Com: Las Vegas XNA Users Group