I'm not aware of any way to do that.   It's not that you couldn't get the data into the chart, it just would have to be using a similar methodology.  ...

I just edited my previous post as there was a dumb error in it that mucks up the values being shown.   I had the wrong table alias in the subquery...

Not sure there are any easy answers here.   If you put the data that sits in SQL 2005 under the auspices of a SQL 2012 box, you'll need to test...

Try this:
CREATE TABLE dbo.Orders (
    OrderID int,
    OptionID int,
    Quantity int
);
INSERT INTO dbo.Orders (OrderID, OptionID, Quantity)
    VALUES    ( 1689310, 4214, 1 ),
            ( 1698321, 5497, 1 ),

And how about some sample data and the CREATE TABLE statements that were asked for?

The way you worded your original post sounds odd.   Why would you expect to run a query against a web service using SQL Server?   If the web service doesn't support...

Probably best to post the query and both plans.   A tad hard to guess based on almost zero information.

So, ... what exactly, do you mean when you say you "can't get it to work" ?   What happens when you run the query?   Please be more detailed than "it...

Think more about the contents of a given index.   For D and E, you're getting what you should have expected.   SQL Server can get everything it needs from the index...

While this is the right idea, we still don't know the data types...