I was a bit disaapointed that the review did not focus on the actual usage of Log PI.
We downloaded a few weeks ago and tested it. It seems quite slow, and had a bug which prevented Log PI from accessing multiple transaction backups in the same disc file. Considering that we backup transactions every hour, its a critical feature -- without it the application is fairly worthless. We contacted the vendor and they have acknowledged the bug. We're waiting to see if the next release fixes the problem.
I realize they are sponsors and the application hasn't been out very long, but a balanced review should highlight such a critical flaw.
My review took 16 hours to complete and was extremely thorough (it's over 20 pages). Believe me, the product was "actually" used. However, I did not test multiple transaction backups. Thank you for pointing out this bug. I am sorry to hear you were disappointed in the product. I thought it was outstanding.
Please note: The assumption is that "multiple transaction backups" mean that the user was putting differential and log back ups to the same file. This is a not a highly recommended practice.
I also downloaded LOG PI in expectations of being able to search a transaction log for a dropped table, or altered table. I had a very difficult time installing and getting the application to run. I felt the installation is poor, the performance is poor and I too want to use more than one transaction log at a time.
As was pointed out the dot net version it installs is out of date and there is no removal for this and that is very troublesome. I have as of yet to get the product to work, after two weeks, and based on my experience I would recommend people not bother with this product. It is more hype than substance.
From your comments, it seems that you had more problems installing, rather than, using the product. In fact, it sounds like you never did use the product. Please identify the particular features you found to be of issue besides the installation and the one that Paul identified (which is extremely obscure). What did you think of the following (please describe your experience)?:
If you had looked at the "actual" screen shots in the review, you would understand how much more detailed this product is then some other competitors (i.e., Apex).
I have some comments from Log P.I. to submit in this forum concerning Paul and Gary's comments:
"We would like to thank both parties for taking the time to review the product and respect both parties’ views and comments, we do not wish to be drawn into a public debate and are more than happy to discuss these, one on one with the individuals concerned, but would like to clarify the following:The impression is created is that Log PI cannot search on a back up file containing multiple log backups, which is not correct in all scenario’s, we have confirmed this bug with the party involved but we do feel the need to clarify the misconception that may arise from the comment. This bug only presents itself when a differential backup is done to the same file as the log backups. The bug is currently being attended to and will be fixed in the new version, due out shortly. All parties that experience installation problems are more than welcome to contact firstname.lastname@example.org. We will endeavor to satisfy all requests, however we do acknowledge that in certain scenario’s that it is not always possible to please all parties.Kind regardsLog PI Management"
"We would like to thank both parties for taking the time to review the product and respect both parties’ views and comments, we do not wish to be drawn into a public debate and are more than happy to discuss these, one on one with the individuals concerned, but would like to clarify the following:
We will endeavor to satisfy all requests, however we do acknowledge that in certain scenario’s that it is not always possible to please all parties.
Log PI Management"
I encourage you to contact Log P.I. support at (345) 945 0873 anytime if you are having problems with the installations, etc. I was very pleased with their level of support. Also, if you feel that there are better/comparible products out there, please feel free to note that in this forum. We are always willing to take a look. However, Log P.I. is well worth the cost. It is packed with features (please see the review).
Mr. Corey, I am not in the habit of lying, as you comments imply, and I am highly insulted by your remarks. If you want me to provide feedback on this ineffective product then sign a contract with me to debug this software otherwise keep your insults to yourself.
I was not insulting you. I was only asking for evidence of your actual review of this product and was looking for details to prove that you had checked it out.
Also, you may address me as Mrs. Corey.
I would love to look at it outside of Log PI's product review. Please contact Steve Jones.