Unfortunately, you really can't accurately look at one index recommendation in isolation. You really have to consider indexes in toto, including a minimum of missing index and existing index usage info. Queries to do that below. This is especially true if you haven't yet verified that you have the best clustered indexes on every (major) table yet.
USE [<your_db_name_here>]
SET DEADLOCK_PRIORITY LOW --probably irrelevant, but just in case
DECLARE @list_missing_indexes bit
DECLARE @table_name_pattern sysname
--NOTE: showing missing indexes can take some time; set to 0 if you don't want to wait.
SET @list_missing_indexes = 1
SET @table_name_pattern = '%' --'%'=all tables.
--SET @table_name_pattern = '%'
PRINT 'Started @ ' + CONVERT(varchar(30), GETDATE(), 120)
IF @list_missing_indexes = 1
BEGIN
SELECT
GETDATE() AS capture_date,
DB_NAME(mid.database_id) AS Db_Name,
dps.row_count,
OBJECT_NAME(mid.object_id /*, mid.database_id*/) AS Table_Name,
mid.equality_columns, mid.inequality_columns, mid.included_columns,
user_seeks, user_scans, ca1.max_days_active, unique_compiles,
last_user_seek, last_user_scan, avg_total_user_cost, avg_user_impact,
system_seeks, system_scans, last_system_seek, last_system_scan, avg_total_system_cost, avg_system_impact,
mid.statement, mid.object_id, mid.index_handle
FROM sys.dm_db_missing_index_details mid WITH (NOLOCK)
CROSS APPLY (
SELECT DATEDIFF(DAY, create_date, GETDATE()) AS max_days_active FROM sys.databases WHERE name = 'tempdb'
) AS ca1
LEFT OUTER JOIN sys.dm_db_missing_index_groups mig WITH (NOLOCK) ON
mig.index_handle = mid.index_handle
LEFT OUTER JOIN sys.dm_db_missing_index_group_stats migs WITH (NOLOCK) ON
migs.group_handle = mig.index_group_handle
LEFT OUTER JOIN sys.dm_db_partition_stats dps WITH (NOLOCK) ON
dps.object_id = mid.object_id AND
dps.index_id IN (0, 1)
--order by
--DB_NAME, Table_Name, equality_columns
WHERE
1 = 1
AND mid.database_id = DB_ID() --only current db
AND OBJECT_NAME(mid.object_id) LIKE @table_name_pattern
--AND mid.object_id IN (OBJECT_ID('<table_name_1>'), OBJECT_ID('<table_name_2>'))
ORDER BY
--avg_total_user_cost * (user_seeks + user_scans) DESC,
Db_Name, Table_Name, equality_columns, inequality_columns
END --IF
PRINT 'Midpoint @ ' + CONVERT(varchar(30), GETDATE(), 120)
-- list index usage stats (seeks, scans, etc.)
SELECT
ius2.row_num, DB_NAME() AS db_name,
CASE WHEN i.name LIKE ca2.table_name + '%'
THEN '~' + SUBSTRING(i.name, LEN(ca2.table_name) + 1 +
CASE WHEN SUBSTRING(i.name, LEN(ca2.table_name) + 1, 1) = '_' THEN
CASE WHEN SUBSTRING(i.name, LEN(ca2.table_name) + 2, 1) = '_' THEN 2 ELSE 1 END
ELSE 0 END, 200)
ELSE i.name END AS index_name,
CASE WHEN i.is_unique = 0 THEN 'N' ELSE 'Y' END + '.' +
CASE WHEN i.is_primary_key = 0 AND i.is_unique_constraint = 0 THEN 'N' ELSE 'Y' END AS [uniq?],
ca2.table_name,
i.index_id, --ius.user_seeks + ius.user_scans AS total_reads,
dps.row_count,
SUBSTRING(key_cols, 3, 8000) AS key_cols, SUBSTRING(nonkey_cols, 3, 8000) AS nonkey_cols,
ius.user_seeks, ius.user_scans, ius.user_lookups, ius.user_updates,
ius.last_user_seek, ius.last_user_scan, ius.last_user_lookup, ius.last_user_update,
fk.Reference_Count AS fk_ref_count,
DATEDIFF(DAY, CASE WHEN o.create_date > ca1.sql_startup_date THEN o.create_date
ELSE ca1.sql_startup_date END, GETDATE()) AS max_days_active,
FILEGROUP_NAME(i.data_space_id) AS filegroup_name,
ius.system_seeks, ius.system_scans, ius.system_lookups, ius.system_updates,
ius.last_system_seek, ius.last_system_scan, ius.last_system_lookup, ius.last_system_update
FROM sys.indexes i WITH (NOLOCK)
INNER JOIN sys.objects o WITH (NOLOCK) ON
o.object_id = i.object_id
CROSS JOIN (
SELECT create_date AS sql_startup_date FROM sys.databases WHERE name = 'tempdb'
) AS ca1
CROSS APPLY (
SELECT OBJECT_NAME(i.object_id/*, DB_ID()*/) AS table_name
) AS ca2
OUTER APPLY (
SELECT
', ' + COL_NAME(object_id, ic.column_id)
FROM sys.index_columns ic
WHERE
ic.key_ordinal > 0 AND
ic.object_id = i.object_id AND
ic.index_id = i.index_id
ORDER BY
ic.key_ordinal
FOR XML PATH('')
) AS key_cols (key_cols)
OUTER APPLY (
SELECT
', ' + COL_NAME(object_id, ic.column_id)
FROM sys.index_columns ic
WHERE
ic.key_ordinal = 0 AND
ic.object_id = i.object_id AND
ic.index_id = i.index_id
ORDER BY
COL_NAME(object_id, ic.column_id)
FOR XML PATH('')
) AS nonkey_cols (nonkey_cols)
LEFT OUTER JOIN sys.dm_db_partition_stats dps WITH (NOLOCK) ON
dps.object_id = i.object_id AND
dps.index_id = i.index_id
LEFT OUTER JOIN sys.dm_db_index_usage_stats ius WITH (NOLOCK) ON
ius.database_id = DB_ID() AND
ius.object_id = i.object_id AND
ius.index_id = i.index_id
LEFT OUTER JOIN (
SELECT
database_id, object_id, MAX(user_scans) AS user_scans,
ROW_NUMBER() OVER (ORDER BY MAX(user_scans) DESC) AS row_num --user_scans|user_seeks+user_scans
FROM sys.dm_db_index_usage_stats WITH (NOLOCK)
WHERE
database_id = DB_ID()
--AND index_id > 0
GROUP BY
database_id, object_id
) AS ius2 ON
ius2.database_id = DB_ID() AND
ius2.object_id = i.object_id
LEFT OUTER JOIN (
SELECT
referenced_object_id, COUNT(*) AS Reference_Count
FROM sys.foreign_keys
WHERE
is_disabled = 0
GROUP BY
referenced_object_id
) AS fk ON
fk.referenced_object_id = i.object_id
WHERE
i.object_id > 100 AND
i.is_hypothetical = 0 AND
i.type IN (0, 1, 2) AND
o.type NOT IN ( 'IF', 'IT', 'TF', 'TT' ) AND
(
o.name LIKE @table_name_pattern AND
o.name NOT LIKE 'dtprop%' AND
o.name NOT LIKE 'filestream[_]' AND
o.name NOT LIKE 'MSpeer%' AND
o.name NOT LIKE 'MSpub%' AND
--o.name NOT LIKE 'queue[_]%' AND
o.name NOT LIKE 'sys%'
)
--AND OBJECT_NAME(i.object_id /*, DB_ID()*/) IN ('tbl1', 'tbl2', 'tbl3')
ORDER BY
--row_count DESC,
--ius.user_scans DESC,
--ius2.row_num, --user_scans&|user_seeks
db_name, table_name,
-- list clustered index first, if any, then other index(es)
CASE WHEN i.index_id IN (0, 1) THEN 1 ELSE 2 END,
key_cols
PRINT 'Ended @ ' + CONVERT(varchar(30), GETDATE(), 120)
SET DEADLOCK_PRIORITY NORMAL
SQL DBA,SQL Server MVP(07, 08, 09) A socialist is someone who will give you the shirt off *someone else's* back.