All statistics and indexes rebuilt and updated on the order table?
Can you post the execution plans as a SQLPLAN file from the below query, if they exist any more.
select
query_plan
from
sys.dm_exec_query_stats
cross apply
sys.dm_exec_query_plan (plan_handle)
where
sql_handle in
(
0x02000000880e2612bdc1c85889b28ed1a83337436c23418e,
0x020000006d90e92510cd4c7f9a9af4c3c7d68bb4cd95914a,
0x020000007c853201340a85cf70825b9c171de622351e36b1
)