Final update of the day from me... my brain hurts and im going home...
I just did a Alter Index ALL on this table to see what came of it...
Index_id 11 is my problem child:
index_idavg_fragmentation_in_percent
10.179520838203473
20.532145960034752
40.518418036320809
1193.7920077651411
160.89879248101581
:crazy: