SQL Clone
SQLServerCentral is supported by Redgate
Log in  ::  Register  ::  Not logged in

Maintenance Plans - Backups and Removing Old Files

By Andy Warren,

In the past few weeks I've written a few articles about Maintenance Plans:

SQL Maintenance Plans
Maintenance Plans - Behind the Scenes
SQL Maintenance Plans - Under the Covers!

Those covered quite a bit and really I had intended to stop there, but I ran across another little quirk that I needed to investigate - so I decided to document as I went and share! Basically what happened is I had a maintenance plan set to backup all databases once per day and to delete backups older than 2 days. First two days ran fine, the third day failed. Can you guess? Yes, insufficient disk space.

Now you'd think...really...that it would make sense to delete the files first, then do the backup? Here is a screen shot of the maintenance plan history:

That seems to support my theory about the backup running first (look at the 7:31:38 pair). But just to be sure, I turned to another tool I use on occasion for tracking down stuff like this, FileMon. You can download a freeware version of it at www.sysinternals.com. It has the ability to track ALL file access! I started it up and applied a filter:

I started FileMon running and captured the following which shows sqlmaint.exe trying to open the backup file that it's about to create. This is the first activity from sqlmaint.

Further down I captured this:

You don't see this line in the maintenance plan history. What happened is before I ran the job the last time I set the existing .bak file to read only. You can see that it tries to delete the earlier file and fails. So FileMon supports my initial conclusion plus the results from the plan history that the backup runs BEFORE the file deletes.

It's one of those things I hadn't run into before because I try to keep a decent amount of free space on my servers. In this case I needed about 15g for a nightly backup and only had 10g or so free after the second days backup. I really like having two backups on disk, so I'll probably add a separate job that runs a couple minutes prior to the backup to remove the older set of files. Although I could shortcut the issue for now by using a tool like SQLZip, I'd rather put a fix in place that will cause the behavior I prefer (and expected!).

Total article views: 7580 | Views in the last 30 days: 3
Related Articles

backup on maintenance plan doesn't work.

this is about backup and maintenance plan.


Maintenance Plan not deleting physical backup file

SQL 2005, Maintinace Plan not deleting physical backup file


Deleting Old Backup files using T-SQL Script

Delete backup file without using Xp_cmdshell and maintenance plans


Deleting BackUp Files

Deleting BackUp Files in UAT Farm


Deleting Older backups

Deleting Older backups