Adding New Elements to Existing XML Data

Question

Adding New Elements to Existing XML Data

Karl Kieninger

SSC Eights!

Points: 853
More actions
September 7, 2012 at 11:28 am

#281236

say I've got an XML column containing something like this:
<doc>
<heading>
<orderid>1</orderid>
</heading>
<line>
<lineid>1</lineid>
</line>
<line>
<lineid>2</lineid>
</line>
</doc>
Now I am going to change the scheme to require a new element and I need to update all existing records with a new element and default value.
If the element will be a child of heading <heading>
<orderid>1</orderid>
<headinginfo>default</headinginfo>
</heading> which can only appear once I can use "update modify insert" method which has been discussed here and elsewhere.
However if the new element is a child of a repeatable element such as line <line>
<lineid>1</lineid>
<lineinfo>default</lineinfo>
</line>
<line>
<lineid>2</lineid>
<lineinfo>default</lineinfo>
</line>
That method cannot work since insert will fail if it finds multiple insert locations.[A substantial shortcoming IMO.]
In practice my XML is much more complicated so I could not reasonable shred and flatten to do the change and the reconstruct via SQL.
So doubting I'm the first there to run into this, I'm wondering if anyone has a method they have found to efficiently make such changes.
Brute force would be to pull the xml out of record method, apply a transform, externally, and then update it back in. Can we do better?
[Edit: Maybe using regex viable.]
Thanks in advance.

Viewing 5 posts - 1 through 4 (of 4 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic. Login to reply

Arthur Olcot SSCertifiable Points: 6564 More actions · Answer 1

I would use an XQuery flwor expression in your scenario. Here is an example to remodel the xml that you have provided and add the extra nodes to the xml schema:

DECLARE @XML XML

SET @XML = '

<doc>

<heading>

<orderid>1</orderid>

</heading>

<line>

<lineid>1</lineid>

</line>

<line>

<lineid>2</lineid>

</line>

</doc>'

SELECT @XML.query('for $x in /doc

return

<doc>

<heading>

{$x/heading/*}

<headinginfo>default</headinginfo>

</heading>

{

for $y in /doc/line

return

<line>

{$y/*}

<lineinfo>default</lineinfo>

</line>

}

</doc>

')

Karl Kieninger SSC Eights! Points: 853 More actions · Answer 2

arthurolcot (9/7/2012)
I would use an XQuery for expression in your scenario.

I love the solution for the simple example. Sadly the XML I've actually got is, i think, far to large and complex to sue this method.

Thanks.

Arthur Olcot SSCertifiable Points: 6564 More actions · Answer 3

ok, without seeing more of the actual xml it is hard for me to comment on that.

However, have you seen this thread:

http://www.sqlservercentral.com/Forums/Topic1311855-21-1.aspx#bm1312389

I came up with this for someone who had similar requirements to yourself, but this adds a new attribute into every node rather than an element. It could be adapted to add an element instead. If nothing else, it may give you some further ideas on how you could achieve your requirements.

Karl Kieninger SSC Eights! Points: 853 More actions · Answer 4

arthurolcot (9/10/2012)
ok, without seeing more of the actual xml it is hard for me to comment on that.

Fair enough.

However, have you seen this thread:
http://www.sqlservercentral.com/Forums/Topic1311855-21-1.aspx#bm1312389

I did review that thread before posting here. It is what inspired the line in my OP, "In practice my XML is much more complicated so I could not reasonably shred and flatten to do the change and the reconstruct via SQL."

I'm considering a regex solution, I ran across a mention this moring of mdq.XmlTransform at http://beyondrelational.com/modules/2/blogs/111/posts/10204/sql-2008-r2-mds-easter-egg.aspx. Our servers are still running 2008, so that probably doesn't get em there. But I'll be finding out why we haven't upgraded.

Thanks!