Hi
Because you have multiple criteria specified as OR criteria, you need to select District = 1 on each of those criteria.
There WHERE clause will then look something like the following:
WHERE
((([Austin Police Department].Name) Like "*" & [Forms]![Austin Police Department- District 1]![txtSearch2] & "*") AND [Austin Police Department].District = 1)
OR
((([Austin Police Department].Location) Like "*" & [Forms]![Austin Police Department- District 1]![txtSearch2] & "*") AND [Austin Police Department].District = 1)
OR
((([Austin Police Department].[Phone Number]) Like "*" & [Forms]![Austin Police Department- District 1]![txtSearch2] & "*") AND [Austin Police Department].District = 1)
OR
((([Austin Police Department].District) Like "*" & [Forms]![Austin Police Department- District 1]![txtSearch2] & "*"))
OR
((([Austin Police Department].[Position Title]) Like "*" & [Forms]![Austin Police Department- District 1]![txtSearch2] & "*") AND [Austin Police Department].District = 1)
I hope this is clear enough.
Cheers