Hey, not sure all of the steps that I took to resolve my issue, but here's what I recall:
Under Replication Monitor at the Distributer, expand node.
Expland node next to server name (Blue-green book icon)
Right click on any of the publishers and choose Reinitialize all subscriptions. (alternately, you can choose properties and select reinitialize under the Subscriptions tab). This just marks the subscription to be reinitialized.
Next, on Status tab, I clicked Run Agent Now to trigger the snapshot; this is supposed to, in my setup, push the subscription but that didn't happen.
Closing the properties window (if open), I selected the publisher in question so the information appeared in the right pane. Selecting the Publish Folder with the red X, I right clicked and chose Start Synchronizing.
That did it for me; hopefully, I chose the right setting in properties so it doesn't happen again.