http://www.sqlservercentral.com/blogs/juggling_with_sql/2012/01/12/fragmented-index-rebuild-or-reorganize/

Printed 2014/09/18 04:06PM

Fragmented Index – Rebuild or Reorganize ?

By vinaypugalia, 2012/01/12

Introduction

In past, many times I have written on Fragmentation of Indexes and how to Defrag them. You can find some related articles at -

After this, many of my readers have queried me for-

  1. What is the basic difference between ReBuild & ReOrganizing an Index?
  2. When to use what?

So, today I will address these two specific queries and also show a handy TSQL which could be used to remove Index fragmentation.

ReBuilding Index means the Index will be ReBuild from scratch using the same definition of its creation. It is same as using DBCC DBREINDEX. Please note that for new development do no use DBCC DBREINDEX as its deprecated from SQL Server 2005 onwards. It is generally preferred to rebuild OFFLINE. However, rebuild could be done ONLINE by specifying appropriate options.

ReOrganizing Index means the data at the Index leaf will be re-organized and the fragments will be removed to the max possible extent. It is same as using DBCC INDEXDEFRAG. Please note that for new development do no use DBCC DBREINDEX as its deprecated from SQL Server 2005 onwards. ReOrganizing an Index is an ONLINE process.

When to use what – As per Microsoft, the recommendations are as under -

If Avg. Fragmentation < 5%, no action is required

else if 5% < Avg. Fragmentation <= 30%, reorganization is required

else if Avg. Fragmentation > 30%, rebuild is required

So, based on the above recommendations, the below TSQL could be used to serve the purpose -

USE DBName
GO
 
DECLARE @tsql NVARCHAR(MAX)  
DECLARE @fillfactor INT
 
SET @fillfactor = 70 
 
DECLARE @FragmentedIndexs TABLE (IndexID INT,
                                 IndexName VARCHAR(100),
                                 ObjectName VARCHAR(100),
                                 AvgFragmentationInPercent DECIMAL(6,2),
                                 FragmentCount INT,
                                 AvgFragmentSizeInPage DECIMAL(6,2),
                                 IndexDepth INT)
 
--Insert the Details for Fragmented Indexes.
INSERT INTO @FragmentedIndexs
SELECT 
  PS.index_id,
  QUOTENAME(I.name) Name,
  QUOTENAME(DB_NAME()) +'.'+ QUOTENAME(OBJECT_SCHEMA_NAME(I.[object_id])) + '.' + QUOTENAME(OBJECT_NAME(I.[object_id])) ObjectName,
  PS.avg_fragmentation_in_percent,
  PS.fragment_count,
  PS.avg_fragment_size_in_pages,
  PS.index_depth
FROM 
  sys.dm_db_index_physical_stats (DB_ID(), NULL ,NULL, NULL, NULL) AS PS
INNER JOIN sys.indexes AS I 
  ON PS.[object_id]= I.[object_id]
  AND PS.index_id = I.index_id
WHERE
  PS.avg_fragmentation_in_percent > 5  
ORDER BY 
  PS.avg_fragmentation_in_percent DESC
 
--Select the details.
SELECT * FROM @FragmentedIndexs
 
--Prepare the Query to REORGANIZE the Indexes
SET @tsql = ''
 
SELECT @tsql = 
  STUFF(( SELECT DISTINCT 
           ';' + 'ALTER INDEX ' + FI.IndexName + ' ON ' + FI.ObjectName + ' REORGANIZE '
          FROM 
           @FragmentedIndexs FI
          WHERE
            FI.AvgFragmentationInPercent <= 30
          FOR XML PATH('')), 1,1,'')
  
SELECT @tsql
PRINT 'REORGANIZING START'
EXEC sp_executesql @tsql 
PRINT 'REORGANIZING END'
 
--Prepare the Query to REBUILD the Indexes
SET @tsql = ''
 
SELECT @tsql = 
  STUFF(( SELECT DISTINCT 
           ';' + 'ALTER INDEX ' + FI.IndexName + ' ON ' + FI.ObjectName + ' REBUILD WITH (FILLFACTOR = ' + CONVERT(VARCHAR(3),@fillfactor) + ') '
          FROM 
           @FragmentedIndexs FI
          WHERE
            FI.AvgFragmentationInPercent > 30
          FOR XML PATH('')), 1,1,'')
  
SELECT @tsql
PRINT 'REBUILD START'
EXEC sp_executesql @tsql
PRINT 'REBUILD END'

Conclusion

To keep the indexes in proper shape, a timely defragmentation is necessary. When to defragment has got no THUMB RULE, it depends on the environment. However, the above script could be scheduled as per ones need to make sure that the indexes gets defragmented when need.


Copyright © 2002-2014 Simple Talk Publishing. All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy. Terms of Use. Report Abuse.