Click here to monitor SSC
SQLServerCentral is supported by Redgate
 
Log in  ::  Register  ::  Not logged in
 
 
 

Software Patents

By Steve Jones,

I highly dislike the current patent system in the US. I think awarding patents for an idea like "1-click purchasing" is a poor practice that discourages innovation. There are numerous problems with our patent system, not the least of which is that it can stifle new ideas and prevent small companies from building on similar ideas that are, well, what I'd all common sense. I don't quite share Richard Stallman's view of software patents, but I do think we have fundamental flaws in the way we handle this intellectual property.

I do, however, think that software has value, and the work we do as software engineers deserves compensation, as noted in this post. We should have some patents, and we should reward those that create truly innovative, and not common sense, ideas in the digital world. How we define those, and how we measure innovation isn't clear to me, but I do think that non-trivial ideas deserve protection.

Our legal systems around the world are slow to catch up to the digital world, and may never do so. As quickly as we can debate patents, copyright, trademarks, and more, the digital world grows, expands, and changes to stretch and challenge our thinking of how the world works. It almost seems as though digital ideas and software defy analogies and explanations that we can relate to the real world.

I don't know how I'd change patents, but I don't want them to go away completely. I do, however, know what I'd do with copyright. I'd change it back to the original system we had, granting 14 years exclusivity to creators, with a single option to renew for 14 years and that's it. The world certainly changes too fast to wait 95 years to use someone else's work.

 
Total article views: 115 | Views in the last 30 days: 1
 
Related Articles
ARTICLE

Digital Storage

Digital technologies have made the transfer of information easier than ever, but what about it's lon...

FORUM

Patent Stupidity

Comments posted to this topic are about the item [B]Patent Stupidity[/B] The whole computer industry...

FORUM

Software Patents

Comments posted to this topic are about the item [B]Software Patents[/B] Well, that 1-click patent b...

ARTICLE

Patent Stupidity

Recent developments such as the Apple vs. Samsung trials, or Oracle's unsuccessful claim that it...

ARTICLE

Secrets and Lies

An fascinating look at security in the digital world.

Tags
editorial    
 
Contribute